Stranger Things Animated Spinoff 'Tales From '85' Criticized as Depressing and Cynical

Variety · 2026-04-23
Stranger Things Animated Spinoff 'Tales From '85' Criticized as Depressing and Cynical

The new animated anthology series, ‘Stranger Things: Tales From ’85,’ has drawn criticism for its bleak and cynical take on the beloved franchise. Unlike typical spinoffs that expand a show’s universe, this series delves into dark, self-contained stories set in 1985 Hawkins, focusing on disillusioned characters and mundane struggles. The animation style is intentionally muted, mirroring the oppressive tone, a stark contrast to the original show’s blend of adventure and heart. Critics argue that ‘Tales From ’85’ mistakes grimness for depth and fails to capture the hopeful spirit that made ‘Stranger Things’ a phenomenon. The anthology format, rather than exploring new lore, presents repetitive, uninspired vignettes that leave viewers with a sense of resignation. This series serves as a cautionary tale about franchise expansion that lacks a clear vision, ultimately diluting the magic of its source material and disappointing fans seeking familiar wonder.